In case you missed it, former ‘That 70’s Show’ star Danny Masterson was sentenced 30 years to life for rape cases that were brought to light in recent years.

As the news of his sentencing spread, another story made headlines revealing Masterson’s former costars, the now-married couple,  Mila Kunis and Ashton Kutcher wrote character letters on Masterson’s behalf ahead of the judge’s ruling. This led to a weirdly PR-riddled “apology” video, celebrity reactions, and folks to dive deeper into past clips of the cast to pick up on any red flags.

That’s when this, now concerning, clip surfaced in which Masterson makes a joke about grabbing his balls to Conan O’Brien. Conan’s reaction, with what we know now, takes on a whole new meaning.